Nanaimo Bar Recipe | A Perfected Classic Recipe + 5 Awesome Tricks (2024)

Who loves Classic Nanaimo Bars as much as I do? My tested-till-perfect, traditional Nanaimo bar recipe includes lots of tricks for an ultra-fluffy filling and perfect layers.

Nanaimo Bars Origin

Nanaimo Bars were invented in the 1950’s in Nanaimo, British Columbia but are popular across Canada. I consider it BC’s best export. In these bars, a nutty, crumbly cocoa crust belies a cool, creamy whipped filling under a silky-smooth chocolate layer.

The chocolate shatters like a creme brulee as your teeth make contact and the layered structure gives way to a mouthful of fluffy, custard and chocolate-y crumbs. ⁠⁠

Nanaimo bar filling traditionally includes custard powder – I opt out for two reasons: the first, it only comes in tubs much bigger than I need for Nanaimo bars, and what the heck would I do with the rest? I have seen enough expired custard powder in my mom’s pantry over the span of my childhood to know this is a single-use item and guess what? I have been making Nanaimos without it for years and have been told by many that they are the BEST EVER (*checks nails, slow tosses hair*). I hope you’ll forgive my bar bragging (bargging?) because I am totally willing to spill all of my secrets below.

And the second, the ingredient list is mostly just artificial flavour, colour and cornstarch. I just make a super-fluffy whipped vanilla filling (but in the recipe you have the option to add custard powder if you like!). ⁠
⁠

Nanaimo Bar Ingredients

It wasn’t until adulthood that I even knew what a nanaimo bar recipe consisted of. Who knew the base was cocoa, sugar, graham crumbs, coconut and nuts. No flour. Such an intriguing combination of flavours that you can’t quite put your finger on but can’t stop nibbling.Here’s what you need:

• Cocoa powder
• Sugar
• Coconut
• Toasted, chopped nuts (walnuts or pecans)
• Soft butter
• Confectioners’ sugar
• Vanilla
• Good quality chocolate (this makes a big difference)
• Vegetable oil (a touch of oil in the chocolate gives it extra sheen and keeps it just soft enough to bite through without the solid crack of a plain chocolate bar)

5 Tricks for Best-Ever Nanaimo Bars:

• For the base, toasting the nuts first builds a lot of beautiful, nutty flavour (vs. the raw, oily flavour of raw nuts). My friend Marnie, a chef, once muttered “why do people who don’t toast nuts even BUY nuts” and I hear her voice in my head every time I’m tempted to skip this step. I simply toast them while the oven is preheating.

• The ultimate trick for the filling is whipping the butter (WHISK ATTACHMENT only if using a stand mixer, paddle will never aerate enough) with confectioners sugar well past the point of combining.

• You want to really aerate that middle layer to a silky fluffiness. If you simply stop mixing when the ingredients come together, you’ll have a thick, over-sweet frosting, kinda pasty in texture. Not what we are going for. Just keep whipping. The mixture will turn a couple of shades lighter and take on a sheen. Then you’ll know it’s done and your patience will be rewarded. (And I will not be offended if you whip in two tablespoons of custard powder.)

• ⁠ To get really beautiful, tidy layers, use an oiled loaf pan that fits inside the baking pan used to make the bars. ⁠Simply oil a loaf pan, the press down the base while still hot, right after it emerges from the oven. Because it’s bound with egg, it puffs up in spots as it baked. ⁠⁠Use the oiled loaf pan again to get the cream layer glass-smooth (you’ll need to be gentle and use side-to-side motion, not a downward press). ⁠

• To get a gorgeous, smooth top layer that you could skate on, do not touch the chocolate with a spoon, spatula, or ANYTHING. Simply pour the cooled-but-pourable chocolate over the chilled filling layer and just tilt the pan around to let the choclate spread naturally across the surface. Let the bars sit undisturbed at room temp until the chocolate hardens. Refrigerating warm-ish chocolate will likely cause (harmless) discolouration. ⁠That’s how you get bakery-looking nanaimo bars.

Storage Instructions

This Nanaimo bar recipe keeps well at room temperature for a couple of days, in the refrigerator for 5 days, or in the freezer for up to a month. You get the best mouthfeel if served at room temperature, but I am personally partial to an occasional frozen bar.

Looking for more cookie plate? I think you’ll love these:

Toblerone Cookies

Peppermint Whoopie Pies

Lemon Pistachio White Chocolate Cookies

Chewy Gingerbread Cookies (I make several pounds of this dough every year!)