Reviews | Exercising Health | Barefoot Strength (2024)

Written by Christopher Ioannou, BSc (Hons) Sports & Exercise Science

Reading Time: 10 minutes

Table of contents

• The Benefits of Barefoot Shoes

• The Problem with Traditional Footwear

• Why Barefoot Shoes Have Not Been Massively Adopted

• Why Vans can work as Barefoot Shoes

  • Zero Drop Soles

  • Thin Soles

  • Removable Inner Sole

• The Build

  • Removing the Inner Soles

  • Replacing the Inner Soles

• Vans as Barefoot Shoes

• Why Vans Are Not Good for Wide Feet and Toe Spread

• Vans as Barefoot Transition Shoes

• How to Transition to Barefoot Shoes Without Getting Injured

• Final Thoughts

They kind of have to, because their thick and cushioned soles blunt the foot's senses and thus fail to stimulate the supporting muscles to hold a strong arch.

The trouble is that all you end up with are even weaker feet and flatter arches as a result.

It's like trying to fix a problem by making another problem.

But, hey, from a monetary perspective, this approach works well because you can now market the “special” arch support as a stand-out feature and even sell them as accessories.

The barefoot shoe industry are no angels either. Many of the brands in this space are exploiting the fact that they are in a niche market by charging pretty exorbitant prices for sometimes pretty averagely made footwear.

And it’s not just me who is saying this. We have received loads of comments from you guys complaining about the current price of barefoot shoes.

Another reason for which wearing barefoot footwear hasn’t been massively adopted is that they are not widely available yet. For example, there is an extremely limited range of barefoot shoes available in South Africa, which is where I'm originally from.

But let me just backtrack a bit to explain how Vans fit into this story.

So, I wore Vans for a few years because they were both stylish and affordable. They are what we’d call great value for money. I'd buy one or two pairs every year and wear them pretty much every day. During this period, while still living in South-Africa, I got into researching barefoot shoes. And after searching for a decently-priced and fashionable pair to replace my Vans, I was completely out of options.

So, I took matters into my own hands and decided to turn my much-loved Vans into barefoot shoes.

I came up with the idea out of necessity due to the state of the barefoot shoe market at the time. My hope is that those who find themselves in a similar predicament will find the following “hack” very useful.

Okay, so let's get this project started then.

Most of the cushioning one feels underneath the foot in these shoes is actually the inner sole layers.

So, it is this inner sole that we are going to change today.

Once you have a good grip, you'll need to start tugging on the inner to work the glue loose. This is a slow and tedious process. It took me almost 5 full minutes to get each one out.

At some points I used the blunt end of a pair of scissors as a wedge between the inner and outer soles to break the really tough bits of glue. However, be careful not to puncture the outer sole with your scissors.

Patience and perseverance is key in this step.

Once you have finally removed the inner sole, tear out any other bits of material that are left behind.

As you can see, the inner sole is made up of multiple layers and is pretty thick. It even has a slightly raised heel, which is definitely not what we want in barefoot-style shoes.

With this thick chunk of material out, there will be less than a centimetre separating your foot from the ground.

Amazon links to similar inner soles can be found below:

U.S. Store

U.K. & Europe Store

To get the right fitting inner, I purchased the one you can cut to size. I then peeled the cotton cloth off the old sole, because it served as both a perfect stencil and finishing touch to this project.

However, before tracing the outline of the cotton cloth on the new inners, I smeared a thin layer of shoe glue onto the cotton cloth and pasted it onto the new inner soles.

I then put a book on it and left it to dry. Two hours later, the soles were ready to be cut to size, following the outline of the cotton cloth from the old sole.

And there you have it – Vans with a significantly thinner sole thickness that mimics those found in many barefoot shoes.

And when you look at them – inside or out – you can't even tell that they’ve been modified.

And since all that excess mass has been removed, the shoes are also much more flexible now, which is another important quality in barefoot shoes.

Furthermore, I’ve found the outer sole to soften with use which further improves the flexibility of these shoes.

Now, despite the great upgrades, I do have one important disclaimer to make in this video, though.

Vans can never be true barefoot shoes because their toe box is not wide enough to accommodate the natural way our toes flatten and spread while walking and running.

You can see how narrow they are when I place an exact outline of my foot over the toe box.

It is for this reason that I eventually stopped wearing Vans, despite making the upgrade to the inner soles.

If you are one of the many people out there who are interested in barefoot shoes, but just can't justify paying the premium price, then Vans, with our recommended adjustments, might be a good compromise for you.

There are also many of you who are still on the fence about whether or not barefoot shoes are the way to go. Well, this might be a good experiment... sort of a transition shoe that is both affordable and familiar.

Talking about transition, when one first takes this thick piece of cushioning out of one’s shoes, the hard ground becomes highly noticeable. As a result, the muscles and connective tissues in the legs and feet start working harder than they have ever worked in the past.

While this is a good thing – it is the reason for which barefoot shoes are so beneficial – there is one caveat that must be mentioned, namely the risk of developing injuries, specifically what is known as “overuse injuries”.

The truth is that the body needs an adequate amount of preparation and time to condition itself to moving without supportive footwear. Because we have relied on our shoes for support most of our lives, we now need to start training the internal structures to start doing all the work.

Unfortunately, it is the high injury rate that is the main argument against barefoot shoes. We even see it in the academic literature.

However, upon further investigation, it became clear that the risk was not in the barefoot movement itself, but in the lack of preparation for it [1] [2].

So, to reduce this risk, we have carefully put together a scientifically-based Barefoot Shoe Transition Program to take you through all the necessary steps needed to safely prepare and strengthen your feet and the surrounding musculature when changing over to minimal footwear.

Learn more about this programme here.

Okay, so, in conclusion, even though Vans are not the ultimate barefoot shoe, we hope that this little DIY hack can inspire many people to experiment with their Vans to find out what it feels like to wear shoes with excellent ground feel.

I’m extremely confident – and I speak from experience here – that once you have spent enough time feeling the exciting terrain around you, you'll never go back to normal shoes again. It would be like putting a pair of thick gloves over your hands, only to lose the sense of touch and feeling that stimulates and excites our brains each and every day.

On that note, thanks for reading. If you enjoyed this post, subscribe to our YouTube channel or join our newsletter for more Health Science Made Simple.

Until next time. Cheers.