The Difference Between Rose Gold, White Gold and Black Hills Gold (2024)

The Difference Between Rose Gold, White Gold and Black Hills Gold (1)Thinking of buying gold jewelry? Excellent choice! From gold wedding bands, to white gold engagement rings to rose gold jewelry sets--gold is consistently in high demand in the jewelry market. Why? Well, fewer metals are regarded as highly for their quality, aesthetic and lifespan as gold. Simply put: gold is timeless! If it wasn’t such a classic, it wouldn’t be available in so many different styles and colors.

Speaking of gold colors, what was once a predominantly yellow gold jewelry market has evolved through various colors and now we’re seeing a massive boom in rose gold jewelry. Is rose gold the new gold? Is white gold less pure than yellow gold? Is yellow gold outdated?

No doubt, you’ve got questions. Fortunately, we’ve got answers! Truth is, there’s a lot to consider when buying gold jewelry, especially when it comes to choosing the perfect color.

Before you invest in fine gold jewelry, there are factors you’ll want to consider. For example, which is more durable and which requires long-term maintenance? What’s the difference between rose gold, white gold and Black Hills Gold?

For starters, yellow gold is the only pure form of gold, but each of these gold colors contains yellow gold. Depending on the gold karatage, alloy metals are used to strengthen gold as it’s simply too soft on its own. This means any gold jewelry that is not yellow gold contains alloys that change its color and properties.

Allow us to elaborate by explaining the key features of rose gold, white gold and Black Hills Gold. First up...

The Difference Between Rose Gold, White Gold and Black Hills Gold (2)

Rose Gold Jewelry

You know and love it, right? How could you not? It’s pink! Ok, back to the subject at hand: what is rose gold? Well, rose gold is simply yellow gold that’s been mixed with a copper and nickel alloy to create that romantic rosy hue. You may notice that some rose gold jewelry pieces are more brightly pink and others are more deep, almost reddish? The color of the rose gold piece ultimately correlates to how much nickel and copper are used in the alloy. For instance, the more nickel, the redder the rose gold will appear.

Is there a standard mixture for rose gold? Most often, rose gold contains 75% gold and 25% copper. If rose gold contains 75% gold, it’s considered 18k rose gold.

To learn more about rose gold jewelry, don’t miss our ultimate buyer’s guide to rose gold vs. yellow gold, which elaborates on value, fashion trends, styling, durability, and more!
The Difference Between Rose Gold, White Gold and Black Hills Gold (3)

White Gold Jewelry

There are few jewelry metals as sparkling and brilliant as white gold. But, what is white gold and how does it get its pristine color? Is white gold real gold?

Absolutely! White gold is simply yellow gold that’s been alloyed with a mixture of metals and often plated after to create a white finish. Generally, white gold is mixed with nickel or palladium, depending on what type of jewelry piece it is.

Generally, white gold contains rhodium plating which is a coating around the gold in order to strengthen and protect the metal. Additionally, rhodium plating creates a smooth sheen and resists scratching and tarnishing. Need more info? We’ve got you covered with all the details explaining rhodium plating and whether or not it’s right for you.

While rhodium-plating white gold jewelry creates a gorgeous luster that also strengthens the jewelry, over time and with daily wear your white gold jewelry will require replating. It’s important to factor replating into the long-term maintenance of your jewelry as it will preserve the lifespan, but also accrue additional costs.

Among the gold shades, rhodium plating is unique to white gold jewelry, as rose gold and Black Hills gold do not require rhodium plating.

The Difference Between Rose Gold, White Gold and Black Hills Gold (4)Pictured above:Gold-quartz placer nugget from the Black Hills of South Dakota, USA | Image credit:James St. John on Flickr,CC BY-ND 2.0

Black Hills Gold

If you haven’t heard of the Black Hills, then you haven’t been to South Dakota or seen the infamous Doris Day western, Calamity Jane. Don’t worry, we’ll help you catch up:

The Black Hills are in South Dakota, one of the major mining meccas for gold in the United States. In fact, the Black Hills Mine in Lead, South Dakota produced 10% of the world’s gold during a span of one hundred years! However, with the Depression, World War II and evolving federal government interaction, the Black Hills Mine inevitably slowed production and finally closed down in 2001.

Gold mining in the Black Hills, once a booming and lucrative industry, is now a song of the past. What’s left, however, is the prevalence of Black Hills gold in jewelry. So, what is Black Hills Gold, is it simply yellow gold? Yes, and no.

Black Hills Gold contains unique characteristics that differ from yellow gold. For example, Black Hills gold jewelry will have natural elements like leaves and grapes, and come in a variety of colors including light green, pink and yellow.

Ultimately, for a jewelry item to be labeled Black Hills Gold, it must be crafted in the Black Hills of South Dakota. However, the gold itself can be mined elsewhere. Most often, you’ll encounter Black Hills Gold rings.

Important note: Black Hills gold is not the same as black gold.

Major Differences Between White Gold, Rose Gold, and Black Hills Gold

As you can see, rose gold, white gold and Black Hills Gold each have their own unique features. Really, the only universal feature among the three is that gold is the main ingredient. Here are the key differences between white gold, rose gold and Black Hills gold:

  • Rose gold has a warm, rosy hue obtained from copper and nickel alloys mixed with yellow gold.

  • White gold is almost always rhodium-plated, which creates a shining luster and enhances its durability. Over time, white gold will require replating, as the yellow beneath may begin to show through.

  • Black Hills Gold is gold jewelry that can be mined anywhere but must be crafted in the Black Hills of South Dakota.

The similarities between these three types of gold jewelry are few, but they each retain an eye-catching uniqueness that sets them apart from other jewelry metals.

And that’s it! Which is your favorite? Ready to shop? Browse our extensive collection of gorgeous gold jewelry, including unique white gold and rose gold jewelry!

SHOP FOR JEWELRY

Gemstone Earrings
Rings
Gemstone Pendants
Necklaces

The Difference Between Rose Gold, White Gold and Black Hills Gold (9)Thinking of buying gold jewelry? Excellent choice! From gold wedding bands, to white gold engagement rings to rose gold jewelry sets--gold is consistently in high demand in the jewelry market. Why? Well, fewer metals are regarded as highly for their quality, aesthetic and lifespan as gold. Simply put: gold is timeless! If it wasn’t such a classic, it wouldn’t be available in so many different styles and colors.

Speaking of gold colors, what was once a predominantly yellow gold jewelry market has evolved through various colors and now we’re seeing a massive boom in rose gold jewelry. Is rose gold the new gold? Is white gold less pure than yellow gold? Is yellow gold outdated?

No doubt, you’ve got questions. Fortunately, we’ve got answers! Truth is, there’s a lot to consider when buying gold jewelry, especially when it comes to choosing the perfect color.

Before you invest in fine gold jewelry, there are factors you’ll want to consider. For example, which is more durable and which requires long-term maintenance? What’s the difference between rose gold, white gold and Black Hills Gold?

For starters, yellow gold is the only pure form of gold, but each of these gold colors contains yellow gold. Depending on the gold karatage, alloy metals are used to strengthen gold as it’s simply too soft on its own. This means any gold jewelry that is not yellow gold contains alloys that change its color and properties.

Allow us to elaborate by explaining the key features of rose gold, white gold and Black Hills Gold. First up...

The Difference Between Rose Gold, White Gold and Black Hills Gold (10)

Rose Gold Jewelry

You know and love it, right? How could you not? It’s pink! Ok, back to the subject at hand: what is rose gold? Well, rose gold is simply yellow gold that’s been mixed with a copper and nickel alloy to create that romantic rosy hue. You may notice that some rose gold jewelry pieces are more brightly pink and others are more deep, almost reddish? The color of the rose gold piece ultimately correlates to how much nickel and copper are used in the alloy. For instance, the more nickel, the redder the rose gold will appear.

Is there a standard mixture for rose gold? Most often, rose gold contains 75% gold and 25% copper. If rose gold contains 75% gold, it’s considered 18k rose gold.

To learn more about rose gold jewelry, don’t miss our ultimate buyer’s guide to rose gold vs. yellow gold, which elaborates on value, fashion trends, styling, durability, and more!
The Difference Between Rose Gold, White Gold and Black Hills Gold (11)

White Gold Jewelry

There are few jewelry metals as sparkling and brilliant as white gold. But, what is white gold and how does it get its pristine color? Is white gold real gold?

Absolutely! White gold is simply yellow gold that’s been alloyed with a mixture of metals and often plated after to create a white finish. Generally, white gold is mixed with nickel or palladium, depending on what type of jewelry piece it is.

Generally, white gold contains rhodium plating which is a coating around the gold in order to strengthen and protect the metal. Additionally, rhodium plating creates a smooth sheen and resists scratching and tarnishing. Need more info? We’ve got you covered with all the details explaining rhodium plating and whether or not it’s right for you.

While rhodium-plating white gold jewelry creates a gorgeous luster that also strengthens the jewelry, over time and with daily wear your white gold jewelry will require replating. It’s important to factor replating into the long-term maintenance of your jewelry as it will preserve the lifespan, but also accrue additional costs.

Among the gold shades, rhodium plating is unique to white gold jewelry, as rose gold and Black Hills gold do not require rhodium plating.

The Difference Between Rose Gold, White Gold and Black Hills Gold (12)Pictured above:Gold-quartz placer nugget from the Black Hills of South Dakota, USA | Image credit:James St. John on Flickr,CC BY-ND 2.0

Black Hills Gold

If you haven’t heard of the Black Hills, then you haven’t been to South Dakota or seen the infamous Doris Day western, Calamity Jane. Don’t worry, we’ll help you catch up:

The Black Hills are in South Dakota, one of the major mining meccas for gold in the United States. In fact, the Black Hills Mine in Lead, South Dakota produced 10% of the world’s gold during a span of one hundred years! However, with the Depression, World War II and evolving federal government interaction, the Black Hills Mine inevitably slowed production and finally closed down in 2001.

Gold mining in the Black Hills, once a booming and lucrative industry, is now a song of the past. What’s left, however, is the prevalence of Black Hills gold in jewelry. So, what is Black Hills Gold, is it simply yellow gold? Yes, and no.

Black Hills Gold contains unique characteristics that differ from yellow gold. For example, Black Hills gold jewelry will have natural elements like leaves and grapes, and come in a variety of colors including light green, pink and yellow.

Ultimately, for a jewelry item to be labeled Black Hills Gold, it must be crafted in the Black Hills of South Dakota. However, the gold itself can be mined elsewhere. Most often, you’ll encounter Black Hills Gold rings.

Important note: Black Hills gold is not the same as black gold.

Major Differences Between White Gold, Rose Gold, and Black Hills Gold

As you can see, rose gold, white gold and Black Hills Gold each have their own unique features. Really, the only universal feature among the three is that gold is the main ingredient. Here are the key differences between white gold, rose gold and Black Hills gold:

  • Rose gold has a warm, rosy hue obtained from copper and nickel alloys mixed with yellow gold.

  • White gold is almost always rhodium-plated, which creates a shining luster and enhances its durability. Over time, white gold will require replating, as the yellow beneath may begin to show through.

  • Black Hills Gold is gold jewelry that can be mined anywhere but must be crafted in the Black Hills of South Dakota.

The similarities between these three types of gold jewelry are few, but they each retain an eye-catching uniqueness that sets them apart from other jewelry metals.

And that’s it! Which is your favorite? Ready to shop? Browse our extensive collection of gorgeous gold jewelry, including unique white gold and rose gold jewelry!

SHOP FOR JEWELRY

Gemstone Earrings
Rings
Gemstone Pendants
Necklaces
The Difference Between Rose Gold, White Gold and Black Hills Gold (2024)

FAQs

What is the difference between rose gold and Black Hills Gold? ›

The 12 karat rose gold leaf is 12 parts copper and 12 parts gold to create the rose gold. The green leaf on Black Hills Gold is 12 karat green gold and is made with 12 parts silver and 12 parts gold.

Which is better, white gold or rose gold? ›

The unique blend of metals in rose gold not only contributes to its durability but also offers resistance to tarnishing and corrosion. This makes rose gold an ideal choice for individuals seeking low-maintenance jewelry that retains its luster over time. Does white gold tarnish? It does not.

What is more expensive gold rose gold or white gold? ›

However, when comparing white gold and rose gold, white gold tends to be more expensive than rose gold. This is mainly due to the fact that white gold is mixed with different metals like silver and palladium, which adds to the cost of producing it.

What are the disadvantages of rose gold? ›

Pros & Cons of Rose Gold
ProsCons
More durable than yellow or white gold.Not hypoallergenic – due to copper in alloy.
Surprisingly affordable.Not as widely available as white or yellow gold rings.
Doesn't require rhodium plating.
Vintage appeal with a romantic connotation.
1 more row

What is so special about Black Hills Gold? ›

Original Black Hills Gold is a unique American art form created the way it was originally made... by hand. No two pieces are alike. Black Hills Gold is a style, a trademark, a tradition of jewelry incorporating a basic design of wild grape clusters with vines and leaves of pink, green and yellow.

Which color is better gold or rose gold? ›

Yellow gold flatters those with olive or dark skin tones best. Unlike yellow gold, rose gold complements all skin tones. Pale skin tones or those with blue undertones shine with 10-karat or other very pink options. Warmer skin tones look gorgeous with higher-karat rose gold pieces with abundant copper in the alloy.

Who should wear rose gold? ›

Pale people with warm, yellowish undertones can really suit rose gold and yellow gold. Some people with dark complexions have cool blue undertones, and can find platinum and white gold pop really beautifully on their skin.

Can you wear rose gold in the shower? ›

Ideally, it's best not to shower with any of your jewelry, However, if it's real gold, you can wear any color of gold in the shower, including yellow gold, white gold, and rose gold.

Is rose gold worth buying? ›

ADVANTAGES OF ROSE GOLD

Gold doesn't rust, tarnish or corrode, and it won't lose its colour over time. It's prized for its lasting beauty that improves with age. Gold is much more malleable than platinum, so it's easier to work into delicate, intricate designs.

Is rose gold a cheap gold? ›

Rose Gold: Often more affordable than high-karat yellow gold because of the lower percentage of gold and the inclusion of less expensive copper alloy. Meanwhile, yellow gold generally carries a higher price reflecting the value and status associated with gold. The higher the karat, the higher the cost.

What karat gold is best for everyday use? ›

Advantages: Most jewelers and consumers love 14k gold for its perfect balance of durability, affordability, and appearance. It's a bright gold that can handle everyday wear. Disadvantages: There is the potential for allergic reactions to the alloy like with 10k gold.

Does rose gold fade? ›

Real rose gold jewelry, which is made of pure gold and metal alloys does not fade. While white gold, which is coated in rhodium to give it a whiter, shinier coating, requires re-coating every few years, rose gold does not require any additional coating to remain lustrous.

Which is best, white gold or rose gold? ›

Rose gold is generally considered to be the more durable option, as it is a mixture of pure gold and copper alloy. White gold, on the other hand, is pure gold, making it less durable. Therefore, rose gold is usually the preferred choice.

Is rose gold good for everyday wear? ›

Rose gold is less prone to damage from everyday wear than white or yellow gold. In fact, rose gold is so durable that it does not require additional plating layers like other variations of gold do. As mentioned above, rose gold does not tarnish with age and its unique patina is adored in the jewelry world.

Is 14K or 18K rose gold better? ›

Its addition to pure gold in order to make rose gold makes rose gold much more durable. The more copper and the less gold, the more durable the metal. Additions of silver and zinc, which also are strong metals, contribute to greater durability as well. This is why 14K rose gold is more durable than 18K rose gold.

Is rose gold the most expensive gold? ›

When it comes to cost, rose gold is generally on par with yellow and white gold. The price of gold is primarily determined by its weight and purity, and since rose gold uses the same amount of gold as its counterparts, the costs are quite similar.

What skin tone is better rose gold or gold? ›

The golden hues of yellow gold complement the golden tones of warm skin. Most warm skin tones also look great in rose gold, which has a similar effect, as well as offering an injection of pink that can brighten up a yellowish complexion. Kind of like how warm skin tones can really benefit from a pop of pink blusher!

Is rose gold the most powerful gold? ›

Yellow gold is known to be incredibly soft, while white gold is only slightly stronger than that. Rose gold, however, is believed to be one of the strongest of all the gold variations. This is thanks to the addition of copper in its mixture, which makes it a naturally heavier and tougher material.

What is the difference between gold and rose gold watch? ›

The primary difference is the combination of alloy metals. Rose gold contains more copper, resulting in a pinkish hue, while 18k yellow gold is alloyed with varying amounts of copper, silver, or zinc to achieve the desired color. Both 18k rose gold and 18k yellow gold are durable options for jewelry.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Mrs. Angelic Larkin

Last Updated:

Views: 6178

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (67 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Mrs. Angelic Larkin

Birthday: 1992-06-28

Address: Apt. 413 8275 Mueller Overpass, South Magnolia, IA 99527-6023

Phone: +6824704719725

Job: District Real-Estate Facilitator

Hobby: Letterboxing, Vacation, Poi, Homebrewing, Mountain biking, Slacklining, Cabaret

Introduction: My name is Mrs. Angelic Larkin, I am a cute, charming, funny, determined, inexpensive, joyous, cheerful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.