What You Should Do If the Insurance Company Offers You a Lowball Settlement in Your Car Accident Case (2024)

What You Should Do If the Insurance Company Offers You a Lowball Settlement in Your Car Accident Case (1)If you were injured in a car accident caused by a negligent driver, you mustfile a claim with their insurance company. You may expect them to treat you fairly and offer you what you deserve when settling your claim.

Unfortunately, the insurance company is a business. As such, their focus may be on making a profit instead of your health and needs. You should not be surprised if they make you a lowball first offer.

What Compensation Should You Receive in Your Car Accident Settlement?

To know if the insurance company is offering a low settlement, you must understand what compensation you are entitled to under California law. You should receive both your past and future damages in your settlement. Types of compensation that should be included in your settlement are:

  • Medical expenses
  • Lost wages and lost earning capacity
  • Pain and suffering
  • Property damages
  • Out-of-pocket expenses
  • Wrongful death damages if a loved one was killed in the collision

How to Respond to a Low Settlement Offer

The insurance company may offer you a low amount in their first settlement offer, hoping you want to settle your claim as fast as possible. This is especially true if you are trying to settle your claim alone. Here is how you should respond to the offer.

Retain a Lawyer

A lowball offer is a red flag that the insurance company is not treating you fairly. If you have not yet hired an experienced San Diego car accident lawyer, you need to do so immediately.They will take over all communications with the insurance adjuster and negotiate your settlement so that you receive the maximum recovery. They will also conduct a thorough investigation into the cause of your auto accident and your injuries and collect the evidence you need to win your case.

Analyze the Offer

While you may understandably feel angry at the insurance company, you must remain calm. Remember that the offer you received is only the first one. Even if the insurance company seriously considered your claim, they would not agree to pay you all you should receive in their first offer.

Your attorney will analyze the offer with you and explain why it is unacceptable. If the insurance company has not explained why they offered you a small settlement, your lawyer will contact them to determine the reasons. This will help your attorney refute any inaccurate facts that led to the low offer.

Reject the Offer

You are not required to accept any settlement offer from the insurance company. If their offer is too low, your lawyer will reject it on your behalf in writing. It is most likely not the last one you receive from the insurance adjuster.

Wait to Settle Your Claim Until You Recover

If you have not fully recovered from your injuries, your lawyer may advise you to wait to settle your claim until you reach your maximum medical improvement (MMI). This is the stage in your medical treatment when you have either:

  • Fully recovered from your injuries; or
  • Recovered as much as you can, and your doctor can give you a final prognosis

It could take months or longer to reach your MMI, especially if you suffered more than one injury. However, you cannot know how much your future damages will be until you reach this stage in your recovery.

Make a Counteroffer

When your lawyer knows how much your claim is really worth, they will make a counteroffer to the insurance company. They will do this in writing to outline the driver’s fault in causing the accident and refute any false claims of the insurance company. They will also explain the seriousness of your injuries, the treatments you need and will need in the future, and the amount of compensation you would accept.

Do not be surprised if the insurance company rejects your first counteroffer. Your attorney and the insurance company may make several offers and counteroffers before your claim is finally settled.

File a Lawsuit

If the insurance company refuses to be reasonable, your attorney will file a lawsuit on your behalf and litigate your claim. While it could take longer to settle your case, the insurance company will likely agree to a fair settlement before your case goes to a jury trial.

Schedule a Free Consultation

Did another driver cause your car accident in San Diego or Southern California? You can start a live chat or call my office to schedule a free consultation.

Related Links:

  • How Do I Know If I Need a Car Accident Lawyer?
  • Evidence Needed in Car Accident Cases
  • 8 Mistakes to Avoid in Your Car Accident Case
What You Should Do If the Insurance Company Offers You a Lowball Settlement in Your Car Accident Case (2024)

FAQs

What You Should Do If the Insurance Company Offers You a Lowball Settlement in Your Car Accident Case? ›

Communicating with the Claims Adjuster

Your legal representative can help you write a letter that states your intentions. Within the letter, you can indicate that you reject the offer and highlight why you deserve a higher settlement amount. You should also counter their reasons for offering the lowball initial offer.

How do you respond to a lowball offer from an insurance company? ›

How to Respond to a Low Settlement Offer
  1. Retain a Lawyer. A lowball offer is a red flag that the insurance company is not treating you fairly. ...
  2. Analyze the Offer. ...
  3. Reject the Offer. ...
  4. Wait to Settle Your Claim Until You Recover. ...
  5. Make a Counteroffer. ...
  6. File a Lawsuit.

How do you counter a lowball settlement offer? ›

Communicating with the Claims Adjuster

Your legal representative can help you write a letter that states your intentions. Within the letter, you can indicate that you reject the offer and highlight why you deserve a higher settlement amount. You should also counter their reasons for offering the lowball initial offer.

How to respond to a settlement offer? ›

If you have determined to respond to a low settlement offer yourself, consider the following:
  1. Stay polite and professional. We understand it's a frustrating and emotional process. ...
  2. Ask questions. ...
  3. Offer the facts. ...
  4. Put your response in writing. ...
  5. Don't be bullied.

What if a car insurance company is not offering enough money? ›

File a Lawsuit

You may need to take your case to court if you cannot negotiate a settlement. Unless you are well-versed in litigation, this is an area for professionals. For that reason, hiring an attorney is advisable at this step, even if you handled negotiations independently.

How do you respond to a low compensation offer? ›

  1. 1 Know your worth. The first step to responding to a lowball job offer is to know your worth. ...
  2. 2 Don't take it personally. ...
  3. 3 Prepare your counteroffer. ...
  4. 4 Choose the right time and medium. ...
  5. 5 Be respectful and positive. ...
  6. 6 Be ready to compromise or walk away. ...
  7. 7 Here's what else to consider.
Aug 15, 2023

How do you respond to a low ball offer? ›

Acknowledge it's a low ball offer

One approach is to simply say that you're willing to negotiate, but that you need to hear a serious starting offer. Another is to counter-offer with a price that's slightly lower than your asking price – even just $1,000 below it.

How do you decline a settlement offer? ›

To reject the initial offer, you will create a counteroffer and send it via mail to the insurance company claims adjuster.

How do you win a lowball offer? ›

Winning Strategies for Lowball Offers
  1. Find Out the Seller's Motivation.
  2. Write a Clean Offer.
  3. Always Counter the Counteroffer.
  4. Divert Attention Away From Price.
  5. Give a Logical Reason Why Your Lowball Offer Is Fair.
Jan 24, 2022

How do I decline a lowball offer? ›

“Thank you so much for the offer. I'm really excited about the company and the role. I want to be upfront with you that the salary is lower than I was expecting based on my skills and experience. I'd like to be at a number more like $X.

Why is the first settlement offer so low? ›

Another reason for these low offers is that insurance companies hope to close the case quickly. They know that the sooner a claim is settled, the less chance there is of new information coming up that could increase the claim's value.

How do you negotiate a better settlement? ›

Tips On Negotiating A Settlement Agreement
  1. Use a solicitor that knows what they're doing. ...
  2. Consider carefully whether the first offer is reasonable. ...
  3. Be patient with your resignation letter. ...
  4. Listen to what your employer has to say. ...
  5. Be realistic and know your worth. ...
  6. Don't undervalue yourself.
Aug 8, 2023

Do insurance adjusters try to lowball? ›

And if you say yes to the amount they put on the table, they escape their liability for a fraction of what they owe. If you've suffered losses related to a personal injury, don't be surprised if an insurance company tries to lowball your compensation. But don't say yes to their offer either.

Will insurance pay more than car is worth? ›

If your totaled vehicle was within the last few model years, the insurance company will offer a payout based on the same year, make and model, even if the amount is higher than what your car is worth.

What happens if insurance doesn't want to settle? ›

When an insurance company refuses to settle, it may be liable for the full amount of the excess judgment after trial, notwithstanding the lower policy limits. This duty of good faith aligns the insurance company's incentives with those of its insured.

Do insurance companies try not to pay? ›

Insurance companies are a business. Their profit is the money they make in premiums minus their expenses and the insurance claims they pay. Like other businesses, they want to increase their profits by controlling expenses like insurance claims. This is why insurance companies try to get out of paying claims.

How do you respond to an offer that is too low? ›

Here is a list of steps on how to respond to a low salary offer:
  1. Ask for time. ...
  2. Understand your minimum acceptable salary. ...
  3. Conduct research. ...
  4. Make a plan. ...
  5. Practice negotiations. ...
  6. Show enthusiasm. ...
  7. Negotiate for early performance reviews. ...
  8. Focus on your skills and expertise.
Feb 2, 2024

Why do insurance companies offer low ball offers? ›

They quickly offer you a lowball settlement in hopes that you'll take it before you learn from a lawyer what your claim is really worth. Don't fall for lowball offer tactics. Contact a lawyer instead. In virtually all cases, a skilled lawyer can get you far more than what the insurer initially offers.

How do you negotiate with an insurance company? ›

8 Insurance Settlement Negotiation Tips
  1. Understand the Insurance Company. ...
  2. Initiate the Claim as Soon as Possible. ...
  3. Never Admit Fault for the Accident. ...
  4. Stick to the Facts, Never Speculate. ...
  5. Know the Rough Value of Your Claim. ...
  6. Be Patient, Do Not Accept the First Offer. ...
  7. Get Everything in Writing.

How do I convince a seller to accept my low offer? ›

Winning Strategies for Lowball Offers
  1. Find Out the Seller's Motivation.
  2. Write a Clean Offer.
  3. Always Counter the Counteroffer.
  4. Divert Attention Away From Price.
  5. Give a Logical Reason Why Your Lowball Offer Is Fair.
Jan 24, 2022

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Carlyn Walter

Last Updated:

Views: 5744

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Carlyn Walter

Birthday: 1996-01-03

Address: Suite 452 40815 Denyse Extensions, Sengermouth, OR 42374

Phone: +8501809515404

Job: Manufacturing Technician

Hobby: Table tennis, Archery, Vacation, Metal detecting, Yo-yoing, Crocheting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Carlyn Walter, I am a lively, glamorous, healthy, clean, powerful, calm, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.