A $500,000 antique tractor? Niche antique markets are thriving, so check the value of old collections (2024)

Nokomis is a small town in south central Illinois with a population just over 2,000. Unassuming though it may seem, Nokomis is home to Aumann Auctions, the world’s leader in the auctioning of antique tractors and collectible farm equipment. Who knew?

“Antique tractors?” I asked when I got owner Kurt Aumann on the phone. “Is that a thing?”

I was trying to be polite, but was picturing huge, rusty old contraptions cluttering the landscape, eyesores in the hayfields. I am, after all, a city girl.

He let out a big chuckle, and said, “You sound like my wife when I first met her. She was from Mississippi. When I told her I collected antique tractors, she said, ‘Nobody collects tractors.’”

Boy, were we wrong.

And, yes, this is a thing. “A Rockwellian kind of nostalgia surrounds old tractors,” Aumann said. “Folks who grew up on farms or around agriculture remember the tractors of those days fondly.”

“And they want a piece of that?”

Apparently. Aumann Auctions sells 2,000 to 2,500 antique and vintage tractors a year, ranging from old steam tractors to those from the 1970s. They can fetch anywhere from $2,000 to over half a million dollars. He sold a 1911 Marshall Colonial Tractor last year for $535,000.

“When selling old farm equipment, the biggest mistake folks make ―especially city-dwellers who inherit a parent’s farm and don’t know what they have ― is not consulting an expert before they put the whole shooting match on Facebook marketplace,” he said.

Just the day before, he said, a woman had been by who had just inherited her father’s tractor collection. A banker, she didn’t know much about her dad’s tractors or their worth. She recalled asking him about them once, and he waved her off, saying, “Oh, you’re just going to sell them to the first person who comes by,” she told Aumann.

And she almost did. As she was clearing out the family farm, someone came by and offered her $150,000 for all 18 of them. She almost accepted but decided to ask around first. Good thing. Aumann estimated they would bring over $400,000, at auction.

Now folks, I am not giving you an excuse to hang onto stuff you don’t need. I am saying know what you have before you give away the farm.

The second time I talked to Aumann, he was in Iowa visiting three farms, all in various stages of downsizing. He had crews working in three other states. “Our business is really rocking right now. Sellers want to get it done before cold weather hits.”

In most cases, folks have a lot of “salvage.” His nice word for junk. They are also often emotionally overwhelmed. A woman he’d met that day was dealing with an Iowa farm her 94-year-old father had just moved from into assisted living. The seven-acre property had seven buildings that were “jam-packed,” plus the house, and more than …. ready for this? … 300 vehicles in various stages of disrepair.

I’m getting hives just listening to this.

“She’s embarrassed about his place,” he said, “but it’s nothing we haven’t seen before. We also know it’s very emotional to watch the home of someone you love get dismantled. We see it clinically and objectively.”

Based on prior jobs, he estimated that two-thirds of what they found would go to salvage and be sold for scrap. “We will cherry-pick the rest. And sell what’s valuable at auction. It’s nothing we can’t handle.”

And instead of a big dirty mess, the daughter and her dad will have a nice check in a clean white envelope.

The loud-and-clear takeaway from Aumann and other niche auctioneers is this:

YOU ARE NOT ALONE:Let this story be a parable. However big your mess, someone else has a bigger one, and experts are available to you help you out from under it.

FIND OUT WHAT YOU HAVE: Whether you have inherited a collection of vintage tractors, or a pile of old silverware, or a closet full of Armani suits, if you think it might be valuable, take the time to check it out before you literally give away the farm.

DON'T SHOOT THE MESSENGER: When you seek out a reputable expert, heed the advice. “They are only trying to help,” said celebrity auctioneer and appraiser Tim Luke, who worked for Christie’s in New York before forming TreasureQuest Group, an auction, appraisal and events company. “They have nothing to gain by telling you something is worth less than it is.”

TAKE THE MONEY AND RUN: Don’t think you’ll get a better offer. As the real estate maxim goes: Your first offer is usually your best. If they tell you there’s not a big market for what you’re selling, don’t wait it out, Luke said. Another appraiser explained it this way: If you have an antique you think is worth $2,500 and you turn down an offer for $1,250, ask yourself: “Would I buy that antique for $1,250?” Because you just did.

UNDERSTAND THE MARKET: Markets change, and you can’t control that. For instance, today the used furniture market is pretty saturated. “This is the first time in history we have two generations downsizing at the same time: Baby boomers and their parents,” Luke said. ”More supply and less demand drives values down.” So be realistic, but do let stuff go.

Syndicated columnist Marni Jameson can be reached at www.marnijameson.com.