Green and social bonds ‘not more risky’ than conventional bonds (2024)

Green, social and sustainability (GSS) bonds are not more risky than conventional bonds, according to one green bond fund manager.

The credit risk of a GSS bond is identical to that of a conventional bond from the same issuer, and so tends to carry the same credit ratings, according toSascha Stallberg, who runs a green bond fund at Nordea.

“Looking at the technical picture, several studies have shown that the historical volatility of green bonds is slightly lower than that of conventional bonds,” he added. “This is attributed to a more long-term focused investor base in green bonds, such as pension funds.”

But Stallberg also said these differences are minor, and that one should not expect a fundamentally different risk-return profile from a portfolio of GSS bonds when compared to identically rated conventional bonds.

Green and social bonds ‘not more risky’ than conventional bonds (1)Even for investors not interested in ESG, there is not a strong argument against investing in GSS bondsSascha Stallberg, Nordea Asset Management

In terms of yield, Stallberg said GSS bonds trade similarly to conventional bonds, but can differ by a small ‘greenium’, i.e. a yield disadvantage of a green bond versus an otherwise identical conventional bond.

“The ‘greenium’ along the German government bond curve currently varies between -4bps {basis points} and +2bps,” he added. “As such, individual green bonds can even have a marginally higher yield than the respective conventional bonds.”

Even for investors who are not interested in ESG, Stallberg said there is not a strong argument against investing in GSS bonds, particularly in the absence of a meaningful ‘greenium’.

Several social and green bond funds have launched over the past few months, including the CT Global Social Bond Fund, the Goldman Sachs USD Green Bond Fund and the UBS (Lux) Fund Solutions – Global Green Bond ESG 1–10 UCITS ETF.

Chloe Cheung is a senior features writer at FTAdviser

Green and social bonds ‘not more risky’ than conventional bonds (2024)

FAQs

Why are green bonds less risky? ›

“Looking at the technical picture, several studies have shown that the historical volatility of green bonds is slightly lower than that of conventional bonds,” he added. “This is attributed to a more long-term focused investor base in green bonds, such as pension funds.”

What is the main difference between green bonds and conventional bonds? ›

Green bonds are a specialized subset of traditional bonds designed explicitly to finance environmentally sustainable projects and initiatives. These projects often focus on areas such as renewable energy, energy efficiency, green buildings, sustainable water management, and climate change adaptation.

What is the most risky type of bond? ›

High-yield or junk bonds typically carry the highest risk among all types of bonds. These bonds are issued by companies or entities with lower credit ratings or creditworthiness, making them more prone to default.

What is the difference between a social bond and a green bond? ›

These different levels of market development / integration are reflected in investors' behaviors: investors are willing to give up 3 basis points for environmental benefits (i.e. when investing in green bonds) but none for social benefits.

Which bonds are the least risky? ›

Treasuries are considered the safest bonds available because they are backed by the “full faith and credit” of the U.S. government. They are quite liquid because certain primary dealers are required to buy Treasuries in large quantities when they are initially sold and then trade them on the secondary market.

What are the advantages of green bonds? ›

Green bonds may offer tax advantages, providing incentives for investing in sustainable projects that do not apply to comparable types of bonds. Investors seeking assets that align with their environmental values should be sure to verify the claims of sustainability made by bond issuers.

What are the advantages of conventional bonds? ›

Advantages of Bonds

Bonds offer coupons or higher interest rate than that of deposits. In addition, the coupon is delivered regularly during the bond tenor. Bondholders can sell their debts to others.

Are green bonds priced differently from conventional bonds? ›

The event study reveals that green bond issuance could reduce the issuer's equity return performance. The regression models found no significant negative green bond premium in either Chinese or global markets, indicating that green bonds are not priced significantly lower than conventional bonds.

Why do banks issue green bonds? ›

1 Climate Change Bonds These bonds are issued to fund projects that focus on mitigating climate change. E.g. renewable energy and energy efficiency projects. 2 Renewable Energy Bonds These bonds are issued to finance projects that create and/or use renewable energy sources. E.g. wind, solar and hydroelectric power.

What makes a bond less risky? ›

Bonds in general are considered less risky than stocks for several reasons: Bonds carry the promise of their issuer to return the face value of the security to the holder at maturity; stocks have no such promise from their issuer.

Which type of bond would be the riskiest to purchase? ›

Non-investment grade bonds, or "junk bonds," are considered higher risk and earn higher returns than investment-grade bonds or U.S. government bonds. However, you also run a higher risk of default, or not getting your money back. You can invest in corporate bonds through a broker.

What makes a bond riskier? ›

All investments contain risk and may lose value. Investing in the bond market is subject to risks, including market, interest rate, issuer, credit, inflation risk, and liquidity risk. The value of most bonds and bond strategies are impacted by changes in interest rates.

What is the difference between green bonds and traditional bonds? ›

The main difference between green bonds and traditional bonds is that the issuer publicly states how it will use the proceeds to fund sustainable projects, allowing the bond to be marketed to investors as green.

What is the difference between social impact bonds and social bonds? ›

Unlike with SIBs, with social bonds, payment of interest and repayment of the capital is not contingent on any measure or outcome being achieved. Social bonds are financial instruments used to finance a project that delivers social outcomes.

Why are green bonds more expensive? ›

From an issuer's point of view, a green bond issuance is more expensive than a conventional issuance due to the need for external review, regular reporting and impact assessments.

Why is there less risk associated with bonds? ›

That's because bondholders are generally entitled to receive the full principal value of their bonds at maturity, regardless of any short-term changes in market value that might have been caused by fluctuations in market interest rates.

What are the downsides of green bonds? ›

Disadvantages of Green Bonds
  • At times, these bonds have drawn criticism regarding the issuer's use of the proceeds. ...
  • These bonds do not have any appropriate rating standards.
  • These bonds might not always provide the liquidity that some investors, primarily institutional investors, may require.
Jan 31, 2024

Why US bonds are considered to be low risk? ›

Ratings agencies assign ratings to a bond based upon the issuer's creditworthiness and financial situation. Fixed-income securities from the U.S. Treasury are backed by the full faith and credit of the United States government, making them very low-risk but relatively low-return investments.

Why are Treasury bonds not risky? ›

Also, T-bonds are backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. federal government, meaning investors won't lose their initial investment. However, since younger investors have a longer time horizon, they typically opt for investments that offer long-term growth.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Rubie Ullrich

Last Updated:

Views: 5442

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (52 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Rubie Ullrich

Birthday: 1998-02-02

Address: 743 Stoltenberg Center, Genovevaville, NJ 59925-3119

Phone: +2202978377583

Job: Administration Engineer

Hobby: Surfing, Sailing, Listening to music, Web surfing, Kitesurfing, Geocaching, Backpacking

Introduction: My name is Rubie Ullrich, I am a enthusiastic, perfect, tender, vivacious, talented, famous, delightful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.